10 Best Bay Rum Aftershaves in 2018

For people who shave almost daily, they are aware that an aftershave is a necessity. The best aftershave is equally important as a shaving cream: it makes the skin have a smooth and appealing look, has the antibacterial properties, and leaves the skin hydrated, toned, and smelling good. And nothing compares to the clean, woody, sweet smell of West Indies bay leaf, Jamaican rum, and spices which comprise the enchanting aroma of bay rum aftershaves. The list below will help you find the best bay rum aftershave in 2018 sorted by their rating in ascending order.

10. Bay Rum Aftershave by Master

For people considering the price factor, this Bay Rum aftershave by Master is quite inexpensive. It has no burning effect which is an advantage especially when you have gone too far with the shave. From the perfect packaging with no leaks to its mild smell, it is a preferable one to those who are sensitive to smell. The fact that it comes in 15 ounces is an assurance that it will last for so long. With absolutely no irritation, it is a perfect product to wear especially when you don’t want to bring too much attention.

Customer rating:

9. Cat O’ Nine Tails Bay Rum After Shave Pour by Captain’s Choice

One major notable feature of the aftershave is the wordings of the bottle. From its clear distinguished title, to how warm the words make you want to purchase it. Made from natural bay leaves and a pint of cloves, it will leave a distinct soothing smell. This is the best bay rum aftershave for people who love a good, invigorating burn after shaving, although it’s not the best-rated. The scent also lasts for a long time leaving a refreshing feeling all day. Most of the customers who reviewed it loved the no-drying effect this aftershave has.

Customer rating:

8. Bay Rum After Shave Lotion by Gabels

This aftershave lotion which weighs 1.1 pounds has a dominant smell of cloves. For those who prefer mild aftershaves, this is arguably the best bay rum aftershave of all time. From being affordable to its quality, it’s very much impossible to hate it. You can tell from the customer reviews that it is an excellent product for people looking for a gentle aftershave that has less burning effect. It has a distinct smell which is less annoying to people and one that lasts for the better part of the day. If you have highly sensitive skin, pairing this with one of the best electric razors for sensitive skin will help reduce any possible side effects.

Customer rating:

7. Genuine Bay Rum Regular by Ogallala

The first thing you notice with the Genuine Ogallala Bay Rum is its clear cobalt blue bottle that comes with a special card which certifies its traditional recipe. It has a distinct smell of bay leaves, sandalwood, and mild vanilla. The scent that emanates from the splash is what placed it among the best bay rum aftershaves of the year. It has a strong scent that will stay up throughout the day. One important advice from the customer reviews is, shake before use at all times.

Customer rating:

6. Bay Rum After Shave with Bay Essential Oil by Turtle Bay Premium

The stylish bottle that comes with it is enough to attract you and make you want to buy it. Oh! And the bottle is reusable. All ingredients are natural with no sheer presence of synthetic fragrance. The firm scent of bay leaves derived from the Caribbean is what dominates, but we can also notice a touch of naturally blended spices. On application, this aftershave relieves the burns from the razor shaves. Customer reviews reveal that they appreciate the packaging but advise on pouring the splash into a different bottle since the flask is unstable. Nevertheless, it might be the best bay rum aftershave for people prone to breakouts.

5. Bay Rum Aftershave Tonic by Bull & Bell

The aftershave is specially designed to relieve razor burns, and it does not dry out skin. Its scent is specially made to last practically the whole day. Distinctively, it is handmade to moisturize the skin and has that soothing effect. It is not sticky at all, and one only needs to apply a small amount on the shaved area. It is a combination of witch hazel and aloe where the outcome is a non-oily effect. Looking at the customer reviews, it leaves the skin smooth and does not irritate, but it’s not quite recommended to those with sensitive skin.

Customer rating:
Best Product

4. Bay Rum Aftershave Splash by Barberry

This one is arguably among the best bay rum aftershave of all time. For people who are health-sensitive, it is entirely safe for your skin. Uniquely, it has no artificial colors or synthetic chemicals and is only made from natural spices and bay leaves essence all the way from the West Indian Island. It is a good moisturizer, and its bay rum is aged for over 30 days. The scent is a distinct blend of bay leaves, cloves, and cinnamon. It reduces irritation caused by wet and dry shaving, which makes it one of the best bay rum aftershaves on this list.

Customer rating:
Cheapest Product

3. Virgin Island Bay Rum by Pinaud Clubman

The body splash is the real deal with the numerous blends of bay leaves and exotic spices contained in the aftershave. It is a perfect toner after shaving and has a soothing and refreshing effect on the skin. For people who prefer a mild, delicious scent, this is definitely the best rum aftershave. It is suitable for any aftershave. If you are looking for a high-quality worthwhile aftershave product, this is one of the best bay rum aftershaves that can go well on almost anybody.

Customer rating:

2. Bay Rum Aftershave by Taylor of Old Bond Street

The aftershave is a two in one which can be used as cologne. The unique smell is what becomes attractive and can last a whole day. The great blend of bay leaves brings out an exotic, refreshing feeling. After applying it, it makes your face smooth and leaves the skin feeling wonderful. It is a product that’s made in England and comes in five fluid ounce bottles. From the customer reviews, it is apparent that the Taylor Old Bond Street is an incredible product that, according to online ratings is the second best bay rum aftershave.

Customer rating:

1. Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion/Cologne by St Johns

The amazing thing about this aftershave is that it’s been handcrafted for 70 years. It’s alcohol-based which acts as an astringent ultimately leaves the face refreshed. Some of its ingredients come from Caribbean fragrances as well as bay leaf oils which have a distinct smell of eucalyptus. It comprises of natural spices hence no worries of present artificial smells. A distinctive feature is its hand-woven palm leaf ‘St Johns’ signature packaging. Its authentic masculine smell can act up as cologne.

The St Johns Bay Rum is long-lasting and has an attractive scent that is quite noticeable. Customer reviews are majorly positive as they comment on its refreshing smell and how they have been using since they were teenagers. It is a product that is hard not to like.

Customer rating:


All in all, the best bay rum aftershave comes from St Johns according to online ratings and reviews; however, Taylor of Old Bond and Pinaud Clubman also have reliable products. that will keep your skin revitalized and glowing with a good intoxicating smell. If you have any questions or experiences you have had with any of the aftershaves above, let us know how it went in the comment section!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This